Lemon97 wrote:
Too young for that... I've looked it up right now... Tim Couch is another great candidate.
Tim Couch is more like David Carr, Derek's older brother. Both were put in charge of expansion teams with weak OL and neither really had a chance to succeed. It was Couch, Smith and Donovan McNabb in the top 3 and only the Eagles got it right, though who's to say if McNabb would have been as good in Cincy? The Bengals were a mess back then and the Eagles had Andy Reid, so maybe any of the 3 would have succeeded in Philly.